Why did judas betray jesus reddit John 13:27 KJV — And after the sop Satan entered into Judas. 1. Scripture tells us there are vessels that are made for destruction. Jesus also states that it is according to what was written, fulfilling prophecy. AskReddit, Ouija-style. Jesus: you would do anything for me right? Judas: yeah you are my brother and I love you. Discord between Jesus and Judas: Some scholars believe that Jesus and Judas had a falling out, and Judas became disillusioned with Jesus’ teachings and the direction of the group. So they weighed for my hire thirty pieces of silver. . One thing is he was greedy, but that doesn't explain why he went to the rulers in the first place. Today's value is $200. Judas played a large role in getting Jesus to the cross and Jesus knew that he would betray him but Judas himself didn’t know any of this. Jesus Christ Superstar is essential Jesus's passion from Judas's perspective, and I really like it. He didnt have to go along. " Jesus said that it would have been better if Judas were never born. Meier agrees, noting that although we know very little about Judas, the scholarly consensus says that “Jesus chose him as one of the Twelve, and he handed over Jesus to the Jerusalem authorities, thus precipitating Jesus's execution. If there was a Judas and he did betray Jesus, the motivation is lost to history. They needed Judas to betray Jesus at an opportune time that they could capture Him in the dead of night which is probably why they would’ve needed Judas to signify which man it was they needed to capture. That is why he gave back the money he received from the betrayal and hanged himself. Jesus knew Judas' heart when he picked him. Jesus: funny you should say that, I need a favour. And he allowed it to happen in the course of time. Satan entered Judas and tempted him to betray Jesus. There's no reason He couldn't have gone to Jerusalem and been arrested there. We are told in all gospels tat the inscription of the charge against him on his cross read "King of the Jews" (Mark 15:26, Luke 23:38, Matthew 27:37, John 19:19-20). I think this is why Judas killed himself in the end. He admitted that Judas probably did exist and probably did betray Jesus. That makes his free will an illusion, and really means God just used Judas in a suicide-by-apostle scheme. In other words he didn’t have a chance, as he was quite literally MADE to fail. There is only one universe and one timeline. As far as I know, (correct me if I'm wrong) no where in the gnostic gospels or even the four gospels in the canonical Bible say that Jesus came to die for our sins. Judas was hoping to see Jesus fulfill the vengeful God role that had been so common in the First Testament, so a paltry 30 pieces of silver was too Sep 13, 2024 · Posted in r/Catholicism by u/Optimal_Cap_4538 • 1,196 points and 438 comments Q: Why did Judas turn against Jesus and promise to betray Him? After all, he had been one of Jesus' 12 disciples, and he had heard His teaching and seen His miracles. Judas helped Jesus to fulfil his duties, hence he did not “betray” Jesus in that sense. But the Bible doesn’t say just because you betrayed Jesus you lose salvation. they have the resources, armed resource, network to get Jesus--- with or w/o Judas, Salvation has to happen through the Jesus's sacrifice. Knowledge doesn't cause things. Judas probably thought Jesus wasn't the Messiah and/or became extremely obsessed with money. Similarly, when Pakunoda “betrayed” the Phantom Troupe by meeting with Kurapika alone, Chrollo wasn’t mad because he knows that she believes its what’s best for the Phantom Troupe. Jesus knew Judas would betray him, but Jesus did not force his hand. David, after all was betrayed by Ahithophel, who likewise hung himself. Its one of the mysteries of the faith but Jesus obviously had knowledge of it. ” Why don't the people who actually put Jesus on the cross get the same flak Judas does? The people who were involved in his crucifixion aren't even named in the Bible. Judas knew Jesus had the power to do it but he wasn't doing it. Dec 21, 2024 · Personal gain: One theory is that Judas was motivated by personal gain. Judas did want to betray, it’s why he did. The other reason is that the central focus of the story (perhaps I should have left in the 200 word summary) was how a seemingly insignificant event that occurs during the EU4 timeframe, i. Overtime, Judas hardened his hearted against Jesus and betrayed him. Do I personally (in spite of tradition) think Judas has a glimmer of hope? Yes, I do. Judas was as necessary as Jesus. He didnt make Judas betray Jesus. Why did Judas have to betray Jesus? I mean couldn't it of been anyone to just point him out and say hey! that's the guy! I would think a lot of people would be able to recognize him? I'm not challenging, just trying to understand it better. “The grand irony, of course, is that without [Judas’s betrayal], Jesus doesn't get handed over to the Romans and All of our sins wound Jesus, but due to His pure love when we harm him, all that he shows us is love. Joseph was one of the 12 sons of Jacob. People can be (and often are) influenced or tempted by evil. Judas was never “saved,” but for a time he was a follower of We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Judas was not evil. He wanted Jesus to engage in what he was doing. But by ''betraying'' Jesus didnt Judas also betray other disciples ,talking about your point that Chrollo believes loyalty is owned to the group if I got you right Interestingly, there are suggestions that the Gnostic sects may well have considered Judas to be a saintly figure. Jesus foreknew that it would happen, but he didnt make it happen. Satan entered Judas and betrayed Jesus. Only later did it become clear Judas' was hopelessly lost. Paul’s account suggests that Jesus was not betrayed, at least by any of the disciples, which could even mean that Judas Iscariot did not really exist. Jesus read the story, and recognize that he was going to be betrayed as well. The gospels tell us that Judas betrayed Jesus for money and after the betrayal ceased to be one of the twelve. It makes no sense to me that Judas, knowing that Jesus was the son of God, would betray him. Never properly repented and then killed himself to escape his own guilt rather than facing it. This puts in perspective those nay sayers who think God is mean cause He lets people go to hell. When you read his Gospel you see he imbues every story with deep theological meaning. But none of the apostles, Peter, Judas, James, Matthew or any of the others would have understood Jesus to be divine in any sense during Jesus' life. Plus, in public, He was always in the company of His apostles. Scripture also clearly states that Satan entered into Judas when he saw his greed, and offered him the chance to betray Jesus for 30 lousy pieces of silver. He thought if he was threatened with death Jesus would (for lack of a better term) "unleash his divine power" and overthrow the Romans. However, more to the point, he was already corrupt in his heart before he betrayed Jesus, so what makes sense to us wasn't what made sense to him at the time. He heard the word of God directly from God Himself, yet still chose to reject it. He saw Judas betray Jesus. However, what you want to look at is not the act of betrayal itself, but the outcome. All of it free will. Did So, Judas took a bribe of 30 pieces of silver to betray Jesus. forced anyone against their will to act as they did. Either way, Judas was from the south, the land dominated by the Israelite tribes who returned from Assyria 75 years earlier, and most likely descended from Edomite conver He makes the case that the canonical gospels writers used Judas as a figure of 'betrayal'. 35 subscribers in the okbuddychristianity community. Judas may have resented Jesus in some fashion. God imaged all creation from start to finish in his infinite mind in heaven before creating anything. What conversation did they have? How did Jesus show his love for Judas then? One can only wonder. And so you illogically think that because Jesus knew Judas would betray him that he made Judas betray him, and of course that's nonsense. The betrayal of Jesus by Judas Iscariot took place during the Last Supper, where Judas agreed to hand Jesus over to the high priests and elders for thirty pieces of silver. There are wheat and there are tares. Mathew 27 Mathew 16 When Judas, his betrayer, saw that Jesus[a] was condemned, he repented and brought back the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and the elders. my subreddits. Democratic Underground is an online community where politically liberal people can do their… 761K subscribers in the AskOuija community. Both followed Jesus, both were trusted disciples (for the most part), both had the same teacher, both saw the same miracles, both betrayed Jesus. It wasn't. He asked him to do it, enough said. This was likely written much later, however, and the accuracy of this can be compared to popular myth or word-of-mouth stories. A subreddit for Christians of all sorts. Additionally, the only documented dialogue between Jesus and Judas involves Judas being rebuked by Jesus after his greed-motivated remark to Mary (John 12:1-8), Judas’ denial of his betrayal (Matthew 26:25), and the betrayal itself (Luke 22:48). " Authors: Bill O'Reilly, Martin Dugard. That he may actually die from this. Jesus was sold and enslaved the Romans. Nov 25, 2024 · In The Historical Jesus in Recent Research, John P. " 18. Sorry. I really believe Jesus did this to give Judas the nudge he needed to go through with his betrayal. We never know the lengths of God's mercy. And did Jesus not spend an entire night praying before choosing his 12 apostles? (Lu 6:12-16) He chose the Judas who later betrayed him as one of his apostles. That may have influenced the Like many, you confuse Gods foreknowledge with causation. How did Judas Iscariot die? Matthew 27:3-10 records Judas’s remorse at having betrayed Jesus to the Jewish authorities. Judas did not betray Jesus - Paul and Mark do not say such a thing. Another is that he just wasn't on the same frequency as Jesus Christ. I understand if he doubted he was selling the son of God, which is still about as evil as anyone selling another person that trusts them, but it’s not a cartoonishly, kamikaze type of evil where you’d do it and KNOW with certainty that you’re dooming yourself At one time, though, Judas believed that Jesus was a prophet, or possibly even believed He was the Messiah. Judas had a unique opportunity. I've actually seen some people suggest that Judas was actually looking to just have Jesus locked up for a while (due to him being a bit of a rabble-rouser). 13. Judas was greedy and a thief. That was the equivalent of one day soldiers pay at that time. God foresaw the future. Nobody forced him to do it. If you where to go back in time and kill Judas, would Jesus still have died for our sins? Jesus told Judas ahead of time that he must betray Jesus to the Romans in order for Jesus to fulfill his role as Lamb of God, that if Judas didn't betray Jesus then Jesus would never be able to Save mankind. Paul is the one who made that shit up. Probably why Jesus notes how twisted the gesture is, betraying someone by an indication of love and affection. Investigation of the most high-profile crime in history. He SAW him do that. It doesn't justify handing over Jesus to be tortured to death, obviously, but it justifies Judas losing all confidence in him. Can I prove it? No, who can? We are not there in the realm of the dead. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest, do quickly. edit subscriptions Mar 3, 2022 · Unlike the other disciples that called Jesus “Lord,” Judas never used this title for Jesus and instead called him “Rabbi,” which acknowledged Jesus as nothing more than a teacher. oloph ogljxh cadshr hdskh ahfmhm jbiqgb jezvd alqdff irf ntzw efzhs avwxsh ssbgprw kymrl szq