Silnylon vs silpoly. X-mids are the other popular option obvs.

Silnylon vs silpoly SilPoly: Short for silicone-coated polyester; similar to silnylon but not used as often. Gatewood Cape uses 30D silnylon. I strongly prefer silpoly in general, but could see the argument for silnylon on, say, a duomid used for 4 seasons. All my tarps look like a shanty town, never got them taut. A couple of disadvantages of DCF that you haven't mentioned. My question is regarding silnylon vs silpoly; im curious how much better is the silpoly is it worth the upgrade? Does the sag on impregnated sil nylon really impact the performance? My YE bonus is coming in and im hoping to purchase myself an upgrade for this up coming season, I can afford either one however im not sure whats a gimic and whats Apr 24, 2022 · Silpoly is less likely to stretch and sag when it rains. I got offered a good deal on a lightly used sil-nylon tarp. My wondering is that 30D might be worth the weight penalty, as silpoly is already more vulnerable than silnylon of equal weight/denier. It seemed surprising to me though since the 1. Meanwhile silpoly is less than 1/2 of the price and DCF is a pain to have to fold every time you want to put it away, plus it takes up a lot more room than What about silnylon? Of course one could make a good case for silnylon, but as far as I can tell, silpoly does everything that silnylon can do, but has added advantages that nylon doesn't have (e. Is there a significant difference between the performance of sil-nylon and sil-poly, especially in arid regions? Thanks! I've used a HG quest, which is 20D silpoly, for years and just got a silpoly thunderfly that I've used on one trip now. 3oz SilNylon, 0. I currently have a membrane silpoly tarp that has one small tear and I fear for it's lifespan, especially around my boys. Apr 8, 2016 · Ripstopbytheroll finished weights. View Profile View Forum Posts Jan 22, 2025 · It also has zero stretch, which makes it easy to get a good tight pitch, but will also stress stakes, stake loops, and poles more than a silnylon in heavy wind due to the shock absorbing stretch that silnylon has. Being square makes many different configurations easily put up and figured out which is nice. 51. Never had an issue with the quest for durability, and I don't have any reason to think the thunderfly will be any different in that regard. View Profile View Forum Posts SilNylon stretches and wets out or soaks in some water when it rains which requires the use of some shock cord guy lines to keep the tarp taught. Silpoly doesn't stretch as much so it's a little tougher to get tight pitches, but it doesn't sag when wet and cold, not nearly as much anyway. Polyester as a fabric does no absorb water, but at the same denier it is not as strong or abrasion resistant as Nylon. 5 osy finished) 30D MTN Silnylon 6. I would say that should be enough testament to its quality. 8 reviews for Stash Jacket. 6, have a pressure rating several times that of the stock American silnylon, and are slightly lighter than stock silnylon. 1. Nylon, however, is hydrophilic, meaning that it absorbs water over time. 1 OSY stuff that Dutch and RSBTR use. 50 at Ripstop By the Roll. I would have to reccomend a sil-nylon poncho as the ultimate, ultralight raingear. 5: Some/Most of the 20d silpoly and 20d silnylon availble to DYI’ers though resellers are not as good as the ones used by some tent manufacturers. 5' tall] from the Sil poly about 8-10 years ago. I found this video from Zpacks, they poke a nail through 1. The current silpoly we carry has a slightly lower waterproof rating than the silnylon, but other than that, the silpoly seems to be pulling ahead. Silpoly. Oct 11, 2018 · Both SilPoly and SilNylon have a lot of variations. I use a WB Blackbird XLC. May 6, 2014 · Silnylon is stronger and doesn't tear as easily. vs. No 10D or 15D silnylons to be found anywhere though. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. It's a silnylon design. I suspect silnylon is as well. Indem du deine individuellen Bedürfnisse und Vorlieben berücksichtigst, kannst du das Material auswählen, das am besten zu dir passt. Nov 18, 2011 · Sil-nylon is great as a tarp, but not very abrasion resistant so its a no go for a groundcloth. I don’t like the sag-when-wet from nylon, therefore decided to go with silpoly. If it was just a tarp, maybe the 15D 0. Silnylon is more tear resistant than silpoly and exists in larger selection of fabrics. Their DST tarp has held up well for me on a lot of trips too. You cannot find a good tent made with DCF upper and a silnylon floor, unless you go to a component (modular) system. 20D and 30D silnylons can be had from 5 or 6 sources. I got rid of mine for a silpoly lunar solo. Silpoly is not as light as DCF, but it packs down to a smaller size than DCF and silnylon. 7D MTN 6. I can get SilNylon for $4. Silnylon absorbs moisture which causes the material to relax, so it looses tautness after setup. Especially with the discount. May 11, 2023 · I’m using silpoly 1. One of its reputed benefits vs silnylon is that it does not stretch and sag when wetted. 9oz silnylon [excellent but heavier], the standard cheap silnylon 20D [OK], the 15D silnylon [ too light for a mountain hunt], the 1. They’re also very hard to get a perfect pitch with if you’re spatially challenged 🥺 and they are so bulky. These look awesome too. Apr 22, 2016 · Cuben’s out of the question due to price. Vor- und Nachteile des jeweiligen Materials für Zelte und Tarps. I can simply patch small punctures or leaks then seam-seal them. The silicone increases the tear strength and makes the material water repellent or waterproof. So on balance, I suspect that Jon is right and silpoly is the greener fabric. Jan 13, 2025 · The LightHeart Gear Rain Jacket (MSRP $150) is a lightweight siliconized polyester (silpoly) waterproof rain jacket made the old-fashioned way, without any so-called waterproof/breathable fabric. Aug 15, 2021 · Hi all, After reading your discussions about polyester vs nylon (thank you for those), I’m still planning on using silnylon for my next tent and was pretty settled on RBTR’s 1. Jun 21, 2022 · Did note that RBTR silpoly has significantly less bias stretch than silnylon; but that could be from the polyester vs the nylon. I think I’m going to go with 20D 1. Oct 19, 2024 · SilPoly vs SilNylon. The Hyperlite Mountain Gear Flat Tarp is a flat tarp with 90-degree corners that can be set up in many different ways or “shapes” depending on weather conditions. Silpoly Vs. Silnylon for snow Silpoly for 3-season with an emphasis on pack ability. Oct 14, 2021 · Naturehike Opalus 2 Tent – silnylon design. e. Jul 1, 2022 · There are both Polyester and Nylon silicone coated fabrics (Silnylon, Silpoly). Dec 25, 2022 #12 sndmn11 Property of TandKhunting. I've recently been doing a fair amount of MN winter camping with my trusty MJ tarp, which I lovebut last weekend it was SUPER windy and although my MJ held strong, I've decided I want a tarp with doors for added protection from the cold winter wind. Some show normal variation; others are actually inferior. I make all my tunnels with silnylon. It is quite strange that you only save 3oz going with DCF. Choosing between Dyneema and Silpoly, or even considering Silnylon vs DCF tents, requires a careful evaluation of these Jun 8, 2023 · Like Dyneema, UltraTNT is what is known as a composite fabric. Joined Jul 2, 2020 Messages 50. 6 oz from RBTR. 74 oz) in white or spruce green Dyneema DCF. Less prone to misting), but others may correct me. . As you surely know, most frequently used material for coating is polyurethane. How does this new MTN silnylon compare against the silpoly and pu coated silpoly in terms of strength, stretch, water absorption, etc? Ron from MLD suggests his new pro silnylon has far less stretch than previous silnylon. Warbonnet says the silpoly stretches less than the nylon but, the silnylon is more durable. It is less tear resistant than silnylon. 0oz Cuben fiber is listed at 3. 3 after) and is used both for rainflys and floors. Please note that we are not currently using Silnylon. While this is relatively new to the tent market, it picks up where silnylon left off and adds some property improvements. Nylon 6. But this type has some downsides, so ultralight advanced tents that are designed to be carried on the trail sometimes SilNylon. 1 oz silnylon or silpoly. Oct 24, 2021 · The most significant cause of tent life is UV, which breaks down fabric fibre molecules and subsequently pulverises and breaks them. December 13, 2020. Roughtly 6oz for DCF vs 10-11oz for Silpoly of the same size as a percentage it seems like a big difference but either one is going to take a respectable chunk out of your BPW vs a tent. I will use for comparison our Silnylon , and the MTN Sil from Ripstop since it has a similar coating as ours and SilPoly from Ripstop. Silpoly, short for silicone-coated polyester, is another waterproof material used in outdoor gear material. If you don't catch it a rip will keep going. DCF (und Ultra) kann man gut abwischen, allerdings funktioniert das mit einem feuchten Lappen nur mäßig gut. The following information refers to the Silnylon that we formerly offered. Jan 10, 2020 · It is further improved by an additional waterproof coating. Both materials have excellent durability and strength, making them popular choices for camping tents, backpacks Dec 13, 2020 · Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly Vor- und Nachteile des jeweiligen Materials für Zelte und Tarps. Thread starter nednic; Start date Apr 13, 2021; Apr 13, 2021 #1 nednic FNG. Apr 26, 2024 · On the other hand silnylon/silpoly can hold a lot of water and of course that means a far heavier shelter to carry around, at least until you get a chance to maybe stop and let it dry out. 6 with Sil/Sil coating (they claim 3000 mm HH). 15D membrane (0. 1 ounces per square yard. I've used an X-Mid Pro 2 for more than a year. I have a 9. 85 oz) and one that’s 8′ x 10′ in size (9. Thread: silnylon vs. I have read to store in a sil nylon bag, which is slippery and less abrasive than DCF. PU4000 would be $7. 8 DCF holds up considerably better and longer than . Silnylon: Key differences and considerations for backpackers Dec 2, 2022 · Silpoly vs Silnylon for Tarps & Tents – Pros & Cons (Overview) Hiking , Backpacking , Camping / By Mikkel Skødt Damsgaard / December 2, 2022 When it comes to choosing materials for tarps and tents, different materials have distinct advantages and disadvantages, and deciding which trade-offs to make is necessary for selecting the “right” one. I'm having a surprisingly difficult time actually finding good hydrostatic head measurements of either. Only thru hikers rival my outdoor time. Brilliant on Henry’s part to offer both fly options, TT’s IG page mentions 30D silnylon being a better choice for “higher elevations or shoulder season”. Both are on sale until tomorrow for I haven't personally made anything with the silpoly yet, but all the feedback I've gotten on the silpoly has been very positive. I made a tipi [12. Mar 31, 2016 · The silpoly vs silnylon durability I mean) Anyhow I really like both of these tarps and I think a 10x10 size encompasses almost anything you want it need to do with a tarp. MLD comes with a sil bag already. 5' silnylon tarp that I adore because it is so packable. Nov 11, 2023 · Please support the creative cottage companies who shoulder the risk in creating new designs. com were the first to be on top of this latest development. Rated 5 out of 5. My plan is to get an 11 foot Superfly. It's lighter and packs down very well. Show Printable Version; 11-11-2018, 14:36 #11. Also, Silpoly isn't that new. I pitched the Yama silpoly flat tarp and my MLD cat-cut silnylon tarp in A-frame configurations, allowed them to stretch a bit while dry, re-tightened their guylines, then measured their mid-panel heights. So these are very similar, but what is the difference between the base core fabrics of nylon and polyester? The core difference is that nylon is hydrophilic, which means it absorbs water which means in lengthened rainfall the fabric tends to start to sag and get heavier. pwq czd lzbb skabxj svtx ozgk klanc gmh oqahp qemlsp jnmv dodw eohwt vowyifwl wyf